What started as a heroic fightback from India on Day 5 of the fourth Test at Old Trafford turned into a hot topic across the cricket world. Under the leadership of Shubman Gill, India showed great resilience to pull off a draw after being under pressure for most of the match.
However, it wasn’t just the result that grabbed attention, it was the decision to reject England captain Ben Stokes’ offer for a draw that sparked widespread debate.
What Happened on Day 5 at Old Trafford?
The fourth Test between India and England at Old Trafford ended in a draw on July 27, 2025, but the final day saw unexpected drama. India, who were trailing in the series 2-1, began the fifth day under pressure. However, a brilliant century by Shubman Gill, KL Rahul’s precious 90 runs, followed by a strong partnership between Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar, brought stability to India’s innings.
As the game moved towards a draw and with just 15 overs left in the day, England captain Ben Stokes offered a draw, signaling to end the game early by shaking hands, a common gesture in Test cricket when neither side can win. But surprisingly, the Indian batters refused the offer and chose to continue batting.
What Did Shubman Gill Say?
After the match, Indian Captain Shubman Gill cleared the air. He said that Jadeja was batting on 89 and Sundar was on 80, and both wanted to continue playing to complete their centuries.
Gill Said – “We felt they batted exceptionally well, and since Jadeja was on 89 and Sundar on 80, we believed they truly deserved to reach their centuries,” He clarified that the decision was not made by the captain or coach, but by the two batters themselves.
Who Decided to Bat On?
Many assumed that India’s head coach Gautam Gambhir or captain Shubman Gill asked the players to continue. However, Gill confirmed that Jadeja and Sundar decided it themselves on the field.
Since the match was already saved, they wanted to complete their individual milestones. There was no pressure from the dressing room. It was a personal call taken by the two players at the crease.
Also read:
Why It Sparked Debate
- Ben Stokes’ Frustration: The England skipper appeared annoyed. Some felt it was against the “spirit of the game” to continue batting when the result was clear.
- Mocking Gesture: England brought in part-time bowler Harry Brook, bowling easy deliveries to make a point.
- Mixed Reactions: While some fans supported Jadeja and Sundar for earning their hundreds, others felt India should have accepted the handshake and ended the match gracefully.
- Stokes’ Comment: He later said he would have walked off if he were in the same position, valuing the team over personal records.
Final Outcome
- India’s second innings ended at 425/4.
- Ravindra Jadeja remained unbeaten on 107, and Washington Sundar on 100.
- The match officially ended in a draw, and England continued to lead the series 2-1 with one Test remaining.
Conclusion
The decision to continue batting wasn’t about disrespect, it was about rewarding two players who fought hard to save the match under pressure. Jadeja and Sundar chose to bat on to complete their well-deserved centuries.
While it surprised many, there was no rule broken, and India ended the game on a strong note. In the end, the team saved the Test and also gave their players a proud personal achievement.
Written by Kinjal Walantra
