Efficient Market Hypothesis: Have you ever wondered why most investors and fund managers fail to beat the market? Why beating the market is considered a big deal?
This can be answered with the help of one of the most controversial theories regarding the stock market- The efficient market theory. Ever since its origin, there has been a lot of heated arguments regarding the validity of this hypothesis.
What is Efficient Market Hypothesis?
The efficient market hypothesis originated in the 1960s and was published by economist Eugene Fama.
The efficient market hypothesis suggests that the current stock price fully reflects all the available information regarding a firm and hence it is impossible to beat the market using the same information.
In other words, you cannot beat the market by using the information that is already available to the public as the market has already incorporated and reflected all the relevant information which may impact the stock.
Here are the few key points that the efficient market hypothesis followers believe:
- Stocks always trade at a fair price and reflects all the available information at a particular time.
- It is impossible to purchase an undervalued stock and sell at an inflated price.
- The only way an investor can possibly obtain a higher return than the market is by investing in riskier stocks.
Why EMH suggests that stocks trade at a fair price?
According to the efficient market hypothesis, the market price of a stock ‘adjusts’ quickly and on average ‘without any bias’ to the new information. As a result, the prices of the securities reflect all the available pieces of information at any given point in time.
That’s why EMH suggests that there is no reason to believe that prices are too high or too low. The security prices adjust before an investor has time to trade or make profits from a new piece of information. An efficient market is fairly priced and an average investor gets exactly what he paid for.
In short, the efficient market hypothesis conveys the slogan- “TRUST MARKET PRICES”.
Three Forms of Efficient Market Hypothesis
There are three different forms of efficient market hypothesis which challenges the different strategies in stock market investing:
1. Weak form EMH:
The weak form of EMH suggests that the current price of a stock fully incorporates information contained in the ‘price history‘ of stocks. Therefore, one cannot take profit by using something that ‘everybody else knows’ and hence cannot beat the market by analyzing past prices.
The weak form EMH directly challenges the technical analysts whose trades are based on past price movements and chart trends.
QUICK READ: Fundamental vs Technical Analysis of Stocks
2. Semi-strong form EMH:
The semi-strong form EMH advocates that the current stock price fully incorporates all the publicly available pieces of information.
All the information like past price movements, financial statements (balance sheet, income statement, annual sheets etc), corporate announcements (like earnings, dividends, bonus etc), economic factors ((inflation, employment etc) are already reflected in the share price. The stock prices get adjusted with the publicly available data and hence, you cannot take advantage by reading what everyone already knows.
This form of EMH suggests that it is useless to read financial statements, industry or economy and make your investment decision based on it. The stock price already reflects these financial data. In short, semi-strong form EMH directly challenges the fundamental analysts who believe in making a profit from the market by studying the fundamentals of a stock
Also read: How to do Fundamental Analysis on Stocks?
3. Strong form EMH:
The strong form EMH proposes that the current price of a stock fully incorporates all the existing information- public or private (insiders information). Hence, nobody should be able to systematically generate profits by trading based on insiders information (which is not even publicly known at the time).
The rationale behind the strong form EMH is that market anticipates the future developments in an unbiased manner and hence the stock price may already have incorporated the information and evaluated it in a much more objective and informative way than insiders.
For example- if a company is on the verge of a revolutionary discovery, the market/public might already have anticipated it and adjusted the price accordingly. Hence, even the insiders cannot take sustained advantage of this new discovery.
All three form of EMH suggests that nobody can systematically beat the market ‘consistently’.
Reasons why Efficient Market Hypothesis may be wrong
There have been a lot of arguments why the efficient market hypothesis may be wrong. Here are the reasons that contradict EMH:
- Many Investors have proven that they can beat the market: Stock market is full of investors like Warren Buffett, Rakesh Jhunjhunwala, Ramesh Damani etc who have consistently beaten the market contradicting the hypothesis.
- Behavioral aspects of Investing: Not all investors behave in a similar manner. Human errors and emotional decisions also influence the prices.
- Regulatory hindrances– There are a number of regulatory hindrances like price bands, circuits, exchange regulations etc which objects the natural movement of stocks.
- Not all investors view stocks in the same manner: EMH presumes that all investors are informed, skilled, can analyze the publicly available data. However, the majority of average investors are not trained and have limited financial expertise.
Although there are many staunch supporters of the efficient market hypothesis, however, this theory has its own limitations.
Those who believe in EMH suggests that the market is efficient and the stocks always trade at a fair price and reflect all the available information. Therefore, they advocate that it’s useless to perform technical or fundamental analysis of stocks as nobody can beat the market using the information which ‘everybody else knows’.
In case the efficient market hypothesis is true, then you should invest all your money in the index fund. This is because- although it is impossible to beat the market, however, by investing in the index fund you can get a similar return as the market.
Hi, I am Kritesh (Tweet me here), an NSE Certified Equity Fundamental Analyst and an electrical engineer (NIT Warangal) by qualification. I have a passion for stocks and have spent my last 4+ years learning, investing and educating people about stock market investing. And so, I am delighted to share my learnings with you. #HappyInvesting